Skip to main content

The Poisoner’s Handbook: Tales of Untraceable Murder and the Roots of Forensics

The Poisoner’s Handbook, written by Pulitzer Prize-winner Deborah Blum and published in 2010, constructs a comprehensive history of forensics and toxicology in New York during the Jazz Age, a period spanning the years of 1915 to 1936. In this work of science writing, Blum explains the complicated chemistry of the most widely used poisons at the time in a way that is simple to understand yet still engaging to read, while also detailing the criminal cases that led to the advancement of forensics. She simultaneously contextualizes the time with vivid and captivating tales of New York City, ranging from the local politics to underground dealings of corrupt coroners and the questionable and grotesque experiments conducted for the sake of progress.

The book is structured like a collection of short stories with each chapter consisting of intriguing cases featuring different poisons being investigated by Dr. Charles Norris, the first chief medical examiner of New York City, and Alexander Gettler, his toxicologist. Together, they advanced the field of forensics from a laughing-stock in criminal court to a respected science necessary for murder investigations. Whether you love the suspense of unraveling a good mystery or just have an interest in chemistry, The Poisoner’s Handbook is a book sure to appease and satisfy.

Blum’s simple yet masterful explanations of the chemistry and applications of each poison are a defining feature of The Poisoner’s Handbook. A prominent example is her description of cyanide and its lethal effects on the victim’s body before their excoriating death:

“Cyanide’s action is murderously precise. It attaches with stunning speed to protein molecules in the blood—called hemoglobins—that carry oxygen throughout the body. Thus the poison is rapidly circulated by the bloodstream and delivered to cells through the body. There it shreds cellular energy mechanisms, breaks down cellular respiration, and causes rapid cell death due to oxygen starvation. Cellular respiration suffers an instant “paralysis,” as Gettler once put it, and the body begins to die. Enzyme production is stymied, electrical signals falter, and as muscle cells and nerve cells explosively fail, body-rattling convulsions frequently result.”

This excerpt on the effects of cyanide is succinct enough to maintain the reader’s attention while also containing the necessary detail and accuracy needed to convey the science. Through her masterful writing, Blum evokes aversive emotions with the vivid descriptions and use of powerful vocabulary and personification of arsenic to demonstrate its vicious nature. Besides that, the science is completely on point. She not only describes the complex mechanisms of arsenic, but also further reveals how the body reacts to it afterwards in a terrifying manner.

The descriptions of the other poisons are just as striking. For example, Blum describes chloroform as a silent killer molecule consisting simply of a carbon atom, a hydrogen atom, and three chlorine atoms. Its overall effect on the body needs no further explanation than the one offered by Frederic Mors, a nurse in the story who murdered several sick elderly patients: “When you give an old person chloroform, it’s like putting a child to sleep.” Reading through Blum’s evocative passages on each poison was certainly a highlight of my reading experience.

The tale of the development of forensics as a science, one of the primary themes of the book, prompted me to ask questions about what the science looks like today. While toxicology has significantly advanced since Gettler’s time, many of his tests developed to identify poisons are still widely being used today in some form. For instance, he was the first scientist to employ spectrometry – an analytical technique still widely used that measures the refraction of light on different molecules and compounds – to identify thallium as the poison used during the criminal investigation of four murdered Brooklyn children in 1935.

The invention of computers, compilations of enormous biological data, and an improved understanding of the nature of many poisons and chemicals have been some of the most important advancements for these fields that allow for analyses now that Gettler and Norris could only dream of in their time. However, they did achieve their goal of proving to the world that forensics is a credible and necessary science and speared the charge of its advancement, so for that we have them to thank.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Dynorphin Signalling: A Pathway to Treating Alcoholism?

     Neuroscientists researching addiction have found that dynorphin, an opioid hormone produced in the brain, may help facilitate the early stages of the learning process by activating specific neural receptors. These findings may seem small at first, but they hold promising implications for the development of future advancements in the treatment of alcohol use disorder (AUD) as these receptors partially influence the brain’s response to alcohol and have many other clinical applications.           Cody Siciliano and investigators of the Siciliano Lab at Vanderbilt University have been researching the role of neurotransmitters in the development of AUD. This disorder, also commonly known as alcoholism or alcohol dependency, affects approximately 29% of adults who drink alcohol in their lifetime. While most people drink to feel that associated buzz, consistently drinking too much can develop into a dependency driven by the need to get rid of t...

The Healing Power of Music

Neuroscientists at the Cambridge Institute for Music Therapy Research have found that music can have positive effects on mood, motivation, concentration, and other cognitive processes. Alexander Street and Jufen Zhang included 201 patients in their 2020 study to assess the effectiveness of a growing treatment option called Neurologic Music Therapy (NMT). This system of clinical techniques is aimed at improving sensorimotor skills, speech and language, and cognition in patients with neurological diseases. During the study, researchers looked for changes in patients’ motivation and mood, concentration, arm and hand functioning, speech and communication, and walking. Of the 201 patients referred to rehab, 177 received this new treatment for two days per week over the course of 24 months, totaling in 675 sessions. As part of the sessions, patients would play drums and percussive instruments to test attention and executive function and sing songs to practice speech, word retrieval and p...